Pricing Strategy: Stop Undercharging and Start Making $10K+/Month

By CJ Critney | For Personal Trainers | 15 min read

If you're training 30 clients to make $5K/month, working 60 hours/week, and feeling burned out, you're doing it wrong. The problem isn't your work ethic. It's your pricing.

Most personal trainers are leaving $50K-100K/year on the table because they're afraid to charge what they're worth.

Let me show you the math that actually works.

The Undercharging Epidemic

The average personal trainer in the US charges $50-70/session. Let's run the numbers:

Metric Low-End Model ($50/session) Premium Model ($150/session)
Sessions to make $5K/month 100 sessions 34 sessions
Sessions per week 25 sessions 9 sessions
Number of clients (4x/month) 25 clients 9 clients
Hours training/week 31 hours 11 hours
Admin/programming time 20 hours 8 hours
Total hours/week 51 hours 19 hours
Sustainability Burnout guaranteed Sustainable for 10+ years

Same $5K/month. One model requires 51 hours/week. The other requires 19 hours/week.

But it gets better. At premium pricing, you can actually work FULL-TIME (30-40 hours/week) and make significantly more:

Premium Model at Full Capacity:

That's life-changing money without sacrificing your life.

Why You're Undercharging

Excuse #1: "I'm new, I can't charge that much."

Wrong. Your clients don't care if you've been training for 1 year or 10 years. They care about results. If you can deliver results (and you can), you can charge premium prices.

Think about it: Would you rather hire a brand-new lawyer who charges $100/hour or an experienced one who charges $300/hour? You'd probably pick the experienced one, right?

But if the new lawyer has a proven track record of winning cases, you'd pay $300/hour. Results matter more than tenure.

Excuse #2: "My area can't support those prices."

Bullshit. I'm in Westlake Village, CA—not Beverly Hills. And I charge $200-250/session. There are trainers in rural areas charging $150+/session.

Premium pricing isn't about geography. It's about positioning. If you position yourself as the best option (through results, specialization, and service), people will pay.

Excuse #3: "I feel guilty charging that much."

This is the big one. You think charging $150/session makes you greedy or out of touch.

Let me reframe this for you:

But asking them to invest $600/month in their health, energy, confidence, and longevity? That's "too expensive"?

You're not selling sessions. You're selling transformation. And transformation is worth way more than $50/hour.

The Premium Pricing Formula

Here's how to price yourself for a sustainable, profitable business:

Step 1: Set Your Target Income

What do you NEED to make to live comfortably and save for the future?

Let's aim for $10K/month as a realistic goal for most trainers within 1-2 years.

Step 2: Determine Your Capacity

How many clients can you realistically serve well?

Sweet spot: 15-20 clients. Enough to make great money, small enough to deliver exceptional service.

Step 3: Reverse-Engineer Your Rate

Goal: $10K/month with 15 clients

$10,000 ÷ 15 clients = $667/client/month

$667 ÷ 12 sessions/month (3x/week) = $56/session minimum

$667 ÷ 8 sessions/month (2x/week) = $83/session minimum

$667 ÷ 4 sessions/month (1x/week) = $167/session minimum

Notice: The less frequently clients train, the higher your per-session rate needs to be.

Most trainers work with clients 2-3x/week. That means you need to charge $80-100/session minimum to hit $10K/month with 15 clients.

But we're not shooting for minimum. We're shooting for premium. Add 30-50% to account for:

Target rate: $120-150/session to reliably hit $10K/month.

The Pricing Ladder (How to Raise Rates Over Time)

Year 1: $100-125/session

You're new, building your reputation. This is still 2-3x what most trainers charge.

Year 2: $125-150/session

You've got 50+ clients under your belt. You have testimonials, results, referrals.

Year 3: $150-200/session

You're established. You have a waitlist. You can be selective.

Year 5+: $200-300/session

You're the best in your area. Clients pay for your expertise and results.

Raise rates every 12 months. No exceptions.

10-20% annual increases. Grandfather existing clients for 6 months if you want to be nice. New clients pay the new rate immediately.

How to Justify Premium Pricing

You can't just slap a $150/session price tag on generic training and expect people to pay. You need to EARN premium pricing through:

1. Results (Track Everything)

Client testimonials that include numbers are worth 10x more than vague "I feel great!"

2. Specialization (Niche Down)

Specialists charge more than generalists.

3. Experience (Build Your Credentials)

4. Service Level (Go Above and Beyond)

What $50/session trainers provide:

What $150+/session trainers provide:

You're not charging more for the same service. You're delivering WAY more value.

Handling Pricing Objections

Objection #1: "That's expensive."

Response: "I understand. Let me break down what you're getting for that investment..."

Then explain the full value:

Objection #2: "My old trainer charged $60/session."

Response: "And how did that work out for you? Are you where you want to be?"

(They're talking to you because they DIDN'T get results with the cheap trainer.)

"You can keep doing what you've been doing and get the same results. Or you can invest in someone who will actually get you there. Your choice."

Objection #3: "I need to think about it."

Response: "Totally understand. What specifically do you need to think about? Is it the price, the time commitment, or something else?"

(This forces them to articulate the REAL objection so you can address it.)

Actually Saying Your Price (Confidently)

This is where most trainers choke. They mumble. They apologize. They give discounts before anyone even asks.

Wrong way: "So, um, my rate is $150 per session... but I can do $120 if that's easier for you?"

Right way: "My rate is $150 per session. Most clients train 2-3 times per week, so that's $1,200-1,800 per month. Does that work with your budget?"

Say it confidently. Pause. Let them respond.

Don't negotiate with yourself. If they push back, THEN you can discuss options (e.g., 2x/week instead of 3x/week to lower monthly cost). But don't drop your rate.

When to Raise Your Rates

For existing clients:

For new clients:

Email template for existing clients:

"Hey [Client],

Quick heads up: Starting [Date 60 days from now], my rates will be increasing from $X to $Y per session to reflect the level of service and results I'm delivering.

You're grandfathered in at the current rate through [Date 6 months from now]. After that, the new rate applies.

If you have any questions, let me know. Otherwise, nothing changes—we keep crushing your goals!

- CJ"

Expected attrition: 5-10% of clients will quit. That's fine. You'll make MORE money with fewer clients at higher rates.

The Bottom Line

You didn't get into personal training to be broke and burned out. You got into it to help people transform their lives.

But here's the truth: You can't help people if you're working 60 hours/week, barely making rent, and hating your job.

Premium pricing isn't greedy. It's sustainable.

Start charging what you're worth. Your clients will pay. Your business will thrive. And you'll actually enjoy being a trainer again.

Ready to Build a Profitable Training Business?

I've spent 13+ years perfecting my pricing strategy, client acquisition systems, and retention frameworks. Now I teach other trainers how to do the same.

Download my free guide: "How to Build a 500-Client PT Business"

Get The Free Guide