How Much Protein Do You ACTUALLY Need?

By CJ Critney | Nutrition | 7 min read

The internet says 1g per pound. Your gym bro says 2g per pound. The government says 0.8g per kg. Who's right? After tracking protein intake for 500+ clients over 13 years, here's what actually works.

The Short Answer

For muscle building: 0.7-1g per lb bodyweight
For fat loss (preserving muscle): 1-1.2g per lb bodyweight
For maintenance: 0.6-0.8g per lb bodyweight

Example (180 lb person):
Building muscle: 126-180g/day
Losing fat: 180-216g/day
Maintenance: 108-144g/day

Why Most People Undereat Protein

The average American eats 50-70g protein per day. That's enough to survive, but NOT enough to build muscle or lose fat effectively.

The result: You train hard, you don't see results, you quit.

My data: 80% of new clients are undereating protein when they start. Once we fix that, results accelerate.

The Science (What Studies Actually Say)

Study #1: The 1.6g/kg Findings

A 2018 meta-analysis in the British Journal of Sports Medicine analyzed 49 studies and found the optimal protein intake for muscle growth is 1.6g per kg bodyweight (0.73g per lb).

Translation: 180 lb person needs 131g protein/day for maximum muscle growth.

Study #2: Higher is Better During Fat Loss

A 2016 study found that eating 2.4g/kg (1.1g/lb) during a calorie deficit preserved MORE muscle than 1.2g/kg.

Translation: When cutting, eat MORE protein to keep your hard-earned muscle.

Study #3: You Can't Overdo It (Within Reason)

Multiple studies show protein intake up to 2.2g/lb has no negative effects on kidney function in healthy people.

Translation: Eating "too much" protein isn't a real concern unless you have pre-existing kidney issues.

My Real-World Protein Guidelines (From 500+ Clients)

If You're Trying to Build Muscle

Target: 0.8-1g per lb bodyweight
Example: 180 lb person = 144-180g/day

Why this works: Enough to maximize muscle protein synthesis without being excessive.

If You're Trying to Lose Fat

Target: 1-1.2g per lb bodyweight
Example: 180 lb person = 180-216g/day

Why this works: Higher protein = more satiety + more muscle preservation in a deficit.

If You're Maintaining

Target: 0.6-0.8g per lb bodyweight
Example: 180 lb person = 108-144g/day

Why this works: Enough to maintain muscle without being obsessive about hitting high numbers.

Common Protein Myths (Debunked)

Myth #1: "You Can Only Absorb 30g Per Meal"

FALSE. Your body can absorb all the protein you eat. The 30g limit is about muscle protein synthesis stimulation, not absorption.

Translation: Eating 60g protein in one meal is fine. It all gets used.

Myth #2: "Too Much Protein Damages Your Kidneys"

FALSE (for healthy people). If you have normal kidney function, high protein intake is safe.

Caveat: If you have kidney disease, talk to your doctor before increasing protein.

Myth #3: "You Need Protein Immediately After Working Out"

MOSTLY FALSE. The "anabolic window" is actually 4-6 hours, not 30 minutes.

Translation: Don't stress about chugging a shake in the locker room. Just get protein within a few hours.

Myth #4: "Plant Protein Doesn't Count"

FALSE. Plant protein counts. It's just less bioavailable than animal protein.

Solution: If you're vegetarian/vegan, aim for the higher end of protein targets (1-1.2g/lb).

How to Hit Your Protein Target

Step 1: Know Your Number

Use the formulas above. Example: 180 lb person building muscle = 144-180g/day.

Step 2: Divide by Meals

If you eat 4 meals/day: 180g ÷ 4 = 45g protein per meal.

Step 3: Use High-Protein Foods

Best protein sources (per 100g):

Step 4: Track for 1 Week

Use MyFitnessPal or similar app. Track everything for 7 days to see where you actually are.

Most people are shocked: "I thought I was eating enough protein. Turns out I was only at 70g/day."

Sample Day of Eating (180g Protein)

Breakfast (40g): 3 eggs + 2 egg whites, 1 cup Greek yogurt

Lunch (45g): 6 oz grilled chicken, 1 cup quinoa, veggies

Snack (30g): Protein shake (1 scoop whey)

Dinner (50g): 8 oz salmon, sweet potato, salad

Evening snack (15g): String cheese + handful almonds

Total: 180g protein

What If You Can't Hit Your Target?

Use protein powder. It's not cheating. It's a tool.

1 scoop whey = 25-30g protein. Add 2 scoops/day and you've added 50-60g to your intake.

My recommendation: Whey protein isolate (fast-digesting, low lactose).

The Bottom Line

Building muscle: 0.8-1g per lb
Losing fat: 1-1.2g per lb
Maintaining: 0.6-0.8g per lb

Most people need to DOUBLE their current protein intake to see results.

Track your intake for 1 week. You'll probably be shocked at how little you're actually eating.

Fix that, and everything else gets easier.

Want a Custom Nutrition Plan?

I'll calculate your exact protein needs and create a meal plan that fits your lifestyle. Results guaranteed.

Book Free Consultation

Are You a Personal Trainer?

Learn how to create effective nutrition plans for YOUR clients and build a $10K+/month training business.

Get The Complete Guide →